
Sam in a Seventh Generation Disposable
Recently, Sam has been in a lot of disposable diapers. He’s been battling a terrible diaper rash (which we now think is due to teething), and the hardcore rash creams are real tough to get out of the cloth diapers in the wash. Sucks, but true. (Note: this would not be a problem with a diaper service, as they have industrial washers that can get most anything out.) Anywhoo, I’m not as down with the regular disposables that are made with chlorine.
Let me tell you — there are a lot of misconceptions out there about so called “green” or “natural” disposable diapers. I certainly love our Earth’s Best and Seventh Generation diapers, but I wouldn’t go so far as to call them “natural.”
One of the big misconceptions is that “natural” disposables are biodegradable. This is absolutely not true. Yes, there are some disposable options that are biodegradable — but these do not include the more popular brands of natural disposable diapers. Seventh Generation, Earth’s Best and Huggies Natural all contain just as much SAP (sodium polyacrylate — the super-absorbent gel that holds your kid’s urine) as regular disposable diapers, and — news flash — that stuff does NOT biodegrade! Even diapers with no SAP — made with absorbent wood pulp — will not degrade in a landfill inside of a plastic trash bag. Nothing does.
What makes these diapers “natural”? The above options contain wood pulp that is not processed with chlorine. This means they may not be as irritating to the skin as other disposable diapers, and it means that the process by which they are made is much more environmentally friendly. (I can’t find a real, solid explanation regarding why chlorine is used to process any kind of diaper material — I assume it is a bleaching process for the wood pulp, which still doesn’t make sense to me.) This process is more “environmentally friendly” because it is not releasing chlorine into the environment. For your baby, this means chlorine-treated wood pulp is not sitting next to the skin. Some of these supposedly eco-friendly diapers boast that they use fewer petrochemicals to make the diapers, though it is not entirely clear what that means. The benefits pretty much end there.
I’m not saying the world wouldn’t be a slightly better place if moms everywhere used chlorine free diapers, but it’s not as huge a step in the right direction as advertising seems to suggest. Those moms who opt for the more “natural” options are still generating a truly staggering amount of trash. When using disposable diapers in this household (we do change frequently, every two hours or so, because of Sam’s propensity to diaper rash), we produce at least two full trash bags of diapers per week. We’ve also raged through 14o diapers in far less than a month. It makes me cringe — that’s just lots and lots of trash. And it’s trash filled with human waste. Gross.
I still advocate for the use of chlorine free diapers — and SAP free diapers, if you find a brand that you like. I still highly advocate for cloth, but until they find something that works as well as goopy, sticky Desitin but doesn’t stain cloth diapers and cause urine to repel right off of them, I’m stuck in the limbo world between disposable and cloth.
Info on your eco-friendly options:
Manufactured with more organic materials: Huggies Pure and Natural ARE manufactured with chlorine — the way the get away with being “natural” is the use of organic cotton in their product.
Chlorine Free: The following brands of diapers are chlorine-free: Seventh Generation, Earth’s Best, Nurtured by Nature, Nature Babycare and 365 (the Whole Foods brand).
Chlorine free and SAP free, and compostable: For the most environmentally friendly choice in disposable diapers, look for Broody Chick, which are 100% compostable and SAP free. (If you’re into composting, or you have a trash center that accepts compost, these are a great option!) Bambo Nature and Attitude are also compostable.
Hybrid options: Flip diapers, gDiapers, and GroVia diapers are all hybrid systems, with waterproof covers and disposable and cloth insert options. For my money, I would recommend the GroVia or gDipaer inserts inside Flip covers. (All of the disposable options are chlorine free, and they are manufactured with far less SAP than conventional diapers. I have found them to be highly absorbent and effective. gDiaper inserts even have a flushable piece that can be torn away, so you are not throwing human waste into the garbage.) These options are more environmentally friendly not only because they contain less SAP and no chlorine — they are just less surface area than regular diapers, and would take up less space in a landfill if used exclusively. The drawback to this system is that breastfed poop can get into the PUL covers, causing you to wash them (a minor pain). But they are fabulous because you will get 100% fewer blowouts because of the way the PUL covers are made (especially the Flip covers — they are bulletproof).
For the money, I would recommend going with Seventh Generation or Earth’s Best if you have an Amazon subscription. (Chlorine free is better for the environment, if only minimally.) In my experience, they work as well as (if not better than) Huggies and Pampers, and they STINK way less. Get Subscribe and Save and Amazon Mom, and you’re set. The other options tend to be far more expensive — though some of them are far better for the environment. Of course, cloth IS best for the environment, particularly if you have an HE washer. If you prefer the convenience of disposables, check out the above options — but remember, anything that goes in a landfill STAYS there. It doesn’t biodegrade … and it doesn’t go away.